Not even Christians believe in the virgin birth

08/12/08 | Posted by Ralph

Last year a piece of research showed that the UK as a nation is a little confused about the details of the story behind Christmas. This year we’re not even sure we believe it. ‘What’s the problem’ you ask? Well, I’m wondering how someone can call himself or herself a Christian and not believe the basics. Even more than that I’m wondering what you think.

image
 Mary and Jesus

The researchers asked the following questions and also asked those questioned what religion they were from – if any. The percentage figures after each question are those that answered yes as ‘historically accurate’ and ‘Christian’ as religion.

Thinking about how Jesus is described in the Bible, do you think each of the following are historically accurate, fictional, or are you unsure if they are historically accurate or not?

1. Jesus was born to a virgin called Mary 42%
2. Jesus was born in Bethlehem 65%
3. Angels visited shepherds to announce the birth of Jesus 36%
4. Herod wanted to kill Jesus, so he ordered the death of infant boys 43%

Percentages of the following are ‘Strongly agree’ + ‘agree’

5. The birth of Jesus is significant to me personally 68%
6. The birth of Jesus remains significant culturally 77%
7. I will be attending a Christmas church service this year 57%

Original research from Theos. Read it for yourself. Last years research is here.

I don’t think this story is owned by Christians and I don’t know how the people who ticked ‘Christian’ define a ‘Christian’. And I don’t think belief in the story is reserved for Christians, it seems by the research that more Muslims believe in the virgin birth than do Christians. More women than men, more older people than younger people and more from up-north than down south believe in the virgin birth. What about you?

Does it matter if we know the details or not any more?
Does it matter if we believe the details or not?
What difference would it make?

Why not relearn the basics yourself just so you can get those quiz answer questions right.

Back to the top

Please bookmark this post at Facebook or Twitter:   Facebook    Twitter

Your comments

I consider myself a Christian, but I don’t believe what’s written in the Bible to the letter. How can I when two separate translations can interpret the same words in different ways? How can I when a lot of it wasn’t written by eye witnesses. It’s a wonderful historical document and an excellent guide to how we should live our lives and what kind of people we should be, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s free from mistake. We’re all human, even those who wrote the Bible, and as humans we can make mistakes. That doesn’t mean that the Bible is less of a valid document or less relevant to me.

#1. By Christine on December 08, 2008

I think that being a follower of Jesus (and therefore God) today has never been further from what a lot of people call being “Christian”. I think that it is meant to be living in each moment in the presence of our Father (which is possible because of what Jesus did).

I believe that Jesus was born from a virgin called Mary through the Holy Spirit and therefore God’s son. I don’t understand why Matthew chapter 1 in the Bible would list the “genealogy of Jesus”. If Jesus’ father is God and Mary was a virgin, then he has no genetic link or ancestry to Joseph’s side of the family and therefore is not genetically a descendent of David or Abraham. It’s a bit confusing. Maybe it means that Jesus is a spiritual son of Abraham and David?

#2. By Jenny on December 08, 2008

I’m a Christian but I believe that worrying about Biblical detail is basically un-Christian.  2 reasons for this:

1) As Christians, we’re followers of Jesus Christ.  He took His guidance mainly from His relationship with God the Father, not from the scriptures, and He didn’t seem to worry about details like who was Cain’s wife etc?  He took God’s Word and made it relevant to the people of His day. 

He also made it possible through the New Covenant for us to have a direct relationship with God and we should be trying to copy His example and listen to what God has to say to us, rather than worrying about the Bible’s accuracy.

2) Following the Bible too literally can lead to some prejudices that are completely wrong in today’s world. They can make us intolerant and unloving.  Jesus stood against these things and, again, it is important that we take His example of love and compassion, rather than live out the prejudices and values of peoples from thousands of years past.

#3. By Jay on December 15, 2008

I think that it is wrong to call yourself a Christian if you don’t believe about the Virgin Birth. Who said we have any right to counter the word of the Bible?

Also, I find it particularly frustrating when people who have no belief in God go accusing Mary of unbelievable things. If they don’t believe in God that is their problem, but they don’t have to go ruining the lives of other people.

#4. By Alice on January 15, 2009

god set natural laws that still work—one such law is that it takes a man and a women to             bring new life into the world that is still true today wheater artificul insimunation or intercourse, ther is now or ever has been any other way its a god law-virgins dont get pregnet without a man being involved and thats the truth

#5. By Mario on April 30, 2009

I don´t belong to religion, but I believe in God, The Virgin Mary and Jesus.

I think that is not a coincidence that God had choosen to Mary as the Mother of Jesus.

I think The Virgin Mary is really special and She is our Mother.

The Virgin Mary left us many teachings.
SHE accepted the will of God with absolutely love, and this is really great, because the man (in general men and women)do what they want and they live in the proud and egotism.

The Virgin Mary and Jesus are the best examples in accepting the Will of God with love.

#6. By Naoko3 on September 23, 2009

hum bug i tell you, hum bug

#7. By Manuel Apodaca on October 07, 2011

I consider myself a Christian but I don’t believe in the bible lol. The rationalizations you guys make. When will you admit that it’s just a book with some nice teachings it it perhaps. But still just a book.

#8. By Dave on October 31, 2011

“Do they not consider the Quran (with care)? Had it been from other than God, they would surely have found therein much contradiction”...Holy Quran 4:82  
**Peace**:)

#9. By Rami on January 27, 2012

Name:

Email:

Comments:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Enter this word:

Search rejesus

Blog post categories

Story, Seasonal,

Facebook

Related modules

RJ is hiring

Rejesus is looking for new content contributors: artists, writers, thinkers, coders, film makers, creatives. If you have a great proposal get in contact.

Categories

arrow Art & image

arrow Articles

arrow Biographical

arrow Downloads

arrow Experiential

arrow How to

arrow Interactive

arrow Interviews

arrow Poetry

arrow Reviews

arrow Seasonal

arrow Sound & vision

If you've found something useful on this site, or use it regularly as a resource, please make a donation here to help us continue.

Latest Blog posts

Queen Accession

Monday (6th February) is the 60th anniversary of the Queen coming to the throne. Whether you are an ardent fan… more

Wheat!

more

Moral news

The Leveson inquiry into how the press behave (following various scandals) has produced some amazing moments. None more so than… more

Seeing things differently at www.mysticchrist.co.uk

prayer christian auschwitz faith abolitionist text message foodball christmas timeline artist interaction amen veronica photo quotable poor office pdf celtic sayings slum mother teresa global warming simon taylor poverty workplace happiness quiz forgiveness golf bishop animation jerusalem nun friar interview course photographer poet nature war theology clouds exercise mark cross freedom plants saint astrophysicist
© copyright
rejesus 2002 to 2012
Powered by ExpressionEngine
Design by Embody